Harry Not Sitting His Tests
doddiemoemoe
doddiemoemoe at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 5 05:49:08 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 167101
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tandra" <tkjones9 at ...> wrote:
>
*snippage of Tandra providing cannon of how few exams harry had
taken during his stay at Hogwars.*
>
Tandra wrote:
> And if he is skipping all these tests, how is he being passed onto
the> next grade? Just something I noticed.
>
> Tandra
>
Doddie here:
Clearly Harry is being passed upon DD's orders...However, I do
believe that he is passed or not passed after DD has conferred to
professors..(hence the one prof. who took it too literally---
Trelawney! LOL (after harry missed an exam she appears to be harder
upon harry and even ron in class.)
Also we must remember in OOP said commentary of the
examiners...where they speak about things DD had done with a Wand
that they had never seen before...(perhaps DD wanted to protect
Harry's abilities--(why else the age restriction of the Tri-Wiz.
Tornament? Why else should DD be in disarray in OOP--is it because
DD truly couldn't instruct his staff...or to have harry develop on
his own to some extent or to gain extra instruction in a non-
ministry approved manner?
Harry shouldn't sit too many tests as his results are privy to the
ministry...the early years of testing mean not to much(but it
allowed DD to keep Harry's academic progress from the
ministry....later years...the ministry would want to take advantage.
( Harry's OWL results were probably the reason why the ministry
tried to press Harry into their service so much during HBP--"O"
DADA, winner of tri-wiz, E in potions, transfig, charms...despite
one of their own making his life miserable..). We as readers do know
that Harry probably did better than anyone at Hogwarts in
DADA....seeing as Hermione didn't get an Outstanding... and the
twins attended his DADA classes-as did Cho and Co... there has to be
something more than books and "schooling"..My theory is that talent
can be nurtured by life, education, expectation, ambition and
expression...individually and cumulatively...Hence one of the
reasons why JKR allowed the "drop-out" twins to be successful in HBP!
I don't think that Voldie had much nurturing... Voldie is on his own-
-as he chooses... Harry is never on his own..even in his most
desolate hours...which means that Harry has a greater development of
self than Riddle ever did...
DD gives us readers our assurance as he states in HPB, "I'm not
worried Harry. I am with you.""(afterwhich not only does Harry have
to disapparate, he has to do "sidealong aparation" .. probably
something voldie never did in his life until the MOM battle in oop..)
Anyhoo....
I think there IS something about the non-sitting of exams...I think
it may have been part of the arrangements of DD, OOP, and even the
mOM ..)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive