[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape: ESE or DDM?

[Bart Lidofsky]

No: HPFGUIDX 167153

From: Lydia French <lydiafrench at gmail.com>
>And in JKR's world, I don't believe that, other than in defense of 
>your own life or the life of another, there are ever situations when 
>a person can willingly and knowingly take the life of another and it 
>not be murder. That is exactly what we are being asked to believe 
>that Snape did and that is why I don't believe that DD would ever ask 
>that of a friend.  

There also seems to be a problem, albeit less so, with extending one's life beyond its natural limits.

Bart