AK and guns- both unforgivable, and sometimes necessary!

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 167166

> Pippin:
<SNIP>
> I think the AK is powered by more than the intent to kill. I think 
it
> is powered by hate, and even Moody's spider could feel it. "almost
> as though it knew what was coming, the third spider scuttled 
> frantically around the bottom of the jar, trying to evade Moody's
> fingers, but he trapped it and placed it on the desk top."
> 
> Dumbledore might have been reconciled to die, but I don't think
> he would be reconciled to hatred. If he had died seeing genuine 
hatred in
> Snape's eyes would he have died in peace?

Alla:

I do find it funny that we agree that there is something really bad 
in AK itself, but do spread in such different directions from that 
realisation.

Let me ask you a question. Strictly hypothetical by the way. I think 
I know the answer from you arguing a ruse, fake AK for the most part 
in the past, but want to be sure.

Just imagine that tomorrow on her website JKR will say ( answers the 
question or just knocks down the false AK) in essense that Snape 
killed Dumbledore with real AK. She will not answer whether Snape 
killed Dumbledore on his orders or not, but will confirm with 
absolute certainty that AK was real. Yes, I know the possibiluity 
that she will answer that is non-existant, but imagine that she did.

If you would know for sure that it was a real AK ( please pretend as 
I said), would it mean for you that Snape cannot be fully DD!M?

Many thanks :)

Alla