will they return to Hogwarts?

julie juli17 at aol.com
Wed Apr 18 21:57:16 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 167722


>
> sweety12783 writes:
>    
>   I think that Harry would return to Hogwarts but as a teacher... 
Remember, Harry was marked by Voldermont as an equal..so the curse 
that is on the DADA position would never harm Harry for he is LV 
equal. That is why Dumbledore looked triumphant when LV used Harry's 
blood to return...Dumbledore knew that by using Harry's blood, LV has 
given Harry the power to defeat him and that LV did not mark Harry as 
a equal until that moment when he used Harry's blood. The scar is 
just a scar resulting from the impact of the AK curse that was put on 
Harry.
>    
>   Just a thought
>
 
Julie:
I don't know if I've read this theory before that Voldemort "marked
Harry as an equal" by using Harry's blood, *not* by leaving him with
the scar mark at DH. (I may have, it just all runs together after
a while!) The scar is more than a scar though, as the rebounded
AK definitely left an effect on Harry, at least in that it gave 
Harry some of Voldy's powers (parselmouth for one), and at most
in that it deposited part of Voldy's soul in Harry (if he is an
"accidental" horcrux).

Your theory about marking Harry though does explain Dumbledore's
triumphant look. Though I still think there might be more to
that look. Maybe it reflects something in Harry's blood, whether
it comes from his genetic heritage (Lily, James) or from the
connection created by Voldemort's failed AK when Harry was still
a baby.

Julie 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive