will they return to Hogwarts?

[Peta-Ann Fox]

No: HPFGUIDX 167840

sweety12783 wrote:

I think that Harry would return to Hogwarts but as a teacher... Remember, Harry was marked by Voldermont as an equal..so the curse that is on the DADA position would never harm Harry for he is LV equal. That is why Dumbledore looked triumphant when LV used Harry's blood to return...Dumbledore knew that by using Harry's blood, LV has given Harry the power to defeat him and that LV did not mark Harry as a equal until that moment when he used Harry's blood. The scar is just a scar resulting from the impact of the AK curse that was put on Harry.

petaannfox:

Hi how are you? What you wrote is an interesting theory, however I will have to disagree about the part where you believe that LV marked Harry as an equal when he used Harry's blood to take humanish form again. 
   
  Why I disagree is that in the OoP (page 742) Harry And Dumbledore discuss the lost prophecy. Dumledore also introduces the fact that the other person could be Neville. Harry questioned if it could be Neville to fight LV but Dumbledore reminds Harry of the second part of the prophecy and quote:
  "You are forgetting the next part of the prophecy, the final identifying feature of the boy who could vanquish Voldemort... Voldemort himself would mark him  his equal. And so he did, Harry. He chose you, not Neville. He gave you the scar that has proved both blessing and curse."
   
  Harry then argues that he might've got it wrong but Dumbledore reasurres him.
   
  The other reason why I disagree with your belief is that LV has got huge tickets on himself and therefore wouldn't take Harry's blood to be equal or mark Harry as equal. (he took it because the spell was blood from a foe, bone from his father - I cant remember the reason and flesh willingly given from servant - Wormtail's arm)
   
  The last reason why I disagree with this is that LV heard the first part of the prophecy. If LV knew the whole prophecy than LV would've left Harry alone or waited until it all pans out - but this is discovered in the OoP in the chapter "The Lost Prophecy".
   
  please write back your views : )

petaannfox