Absolute Crazy Thought - Harry Arisen

Mhochberg at aol.com Mhochberg at aol.com
Fri Apr 20 03:18:00 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 167776

 
 
bboyminn:

Here's the thing, this unlikely theory assumes that  Harry has no idea that a 
Horcrux exists for him. When Voldemort cast the killing  curse against him, 
Harry full expects to die. But what happens if he doesn't?  

What happens if Harry is trapped in the in-between world of  
'vapor!Harry'What happens if Harry is trapped in the in-between world of  'vapor!Harry'<WBR>? 
He is unable to cross over to his 'eternal reward', and is  unable to manifes

Now starting from this point, what are you willing to  do to get Harry back? 
What are you willing to assist Harry in doing, for Harry  to return to defeat 
Voldemort? 

Keep in mind that in this case, the  'flesh of a servant' doesn't have to be 
a hand. It could be just the very tip of  a finger; not even enough to 
permanently damage the finger. The 'blood of an  enemy forcibly taken' could simply 
be Draco allowing Ron to forcibly take some  of  his blood. There really is a 
range of gray here that needs to be  considered.

So, start from that point. Voldemort /kills/ Harry but Harry  doesn't die. He 
remains on earth in a bodiless form. Now what are you willing to  do to get 
Harry back? 

How dark does 'Blood,  Flesh & Bone' seem in this context?
~~~~
Steve, this is a very interesting theory on several  levels. The first 
thought that comes to mind is that it would be a set up for at  least one more book, 
if not a whole series of books. Not-quite-dead Harry would  make an 
interesting part of the trio! This would take the books to a different  level of 
maturity. Handled well, though, it could make for some very interesting  reading. I 
like the idea of shades of gray. 
 
On the other hand, if she decides to kill off Harry, this  could be a good 
way to revive him, similar to Conan Doyle bringing back  Holmes.
 
Thanks for suggesting it. 
 
---Mary, wondering just what dis-embodied Harry would do  for 5 or 10 years.
 
 

 
 







************************************** See what's free at http://www.aol.com.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive