Absolute Crazy Thought - Harry Arisen

[va32h]

No: HPFGUIDX 167781

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Steve" <bboyminn at ...> wrote:
> 
> Here's the thing, this unlikely theory assumes that Harry
> has no idea that a Horcrux exists for him. When Voldemort
> cast the killing curse against him, Harry full expects
> to die. But what happens if he doesn't? 

va32h:
Harry not knowing he has a horcrux wouldn't change the idea of the 
resurrection potion being a piece of very dark magic, of which Harry 
would want no part. At least not Harry as I understand him. 


Steve here: 
> What happens if Harry is trapped in the in-between world
> of 'vapor!Harry'? He is unable to cross over to his 
> 'eternal reward', and is unable to manifest himself in 
> the material world. Is that really how you want Harry to
> remain? 
> 
> Now starting from this point, what are you willing to do
> to get Harry back? What are you willing to assist Harry
> in doing, for Harry to return to defeat Voldemort? 

va32h here:
Well it doesn't really matter what I want does it? What would Harry 
want? I cannot believe that Harry would either want, or allow, his 
friends to participate in an act of Dark magic to bring him back. 

Even to defeat Voldemort - I don't think JKR would throw in a "two 
wrongs do make a right after all" at this point in the story. Harry's 
greatest weapon is his inability to fight evil with evil, but to 
fight it with love insteand. 

Voldemort, in his vaporous state, could still possess people, so if 
we are simply talking about defeating Voldie - Harry could do that 
via possession, and not need to create a new body. 

Steve here: 
> Keep in mind that in this case, the 'flesh of a servant'
> doesn't have to be a hand. It could be just the very tip
> of a finger; not even enough to permanently damage the 
> finger. The 'blood of an enemy forcibly taken' could
> simply be Draco allowing Ron to forcibly take some of 
> his blood. There really is a range of gray here that
> needs to be considered.
> 
> So, start from that point. Voldemort /kills/ Harry but
> Harry doesn't die. He remains on earth in a bodiless
> form. Now what are you willing to do to get Harry back?
> 
> How dark does 'Blood, Flesh & Bone' seem in this context?

va32h here:

Still plenty dark. I really don't see a gray area...Harry's power to 
fight Voldemort comes from his pure, soul, and he will lose that 
power if he resorts to dark magic.  

va32h