Absolute Crazy Thought - Harry Arisen

[jmwcfo]

No: HPFGUIDX 167779

Dave:
> Causing the "willing servant" pain seems to be part of the process.
> Besides, unlike LV, Harry has *friends*, rather than "servants".


JW:
Dobby gleefully chooses to assist Harry in any way possible.  IMHO, 
Dobby could thus be considered a servant.  Besides, we haven't heard 
of any house elves with missing limbs or other body parts.  
Perhaps "elf magic" includes spontaneous regeneration, to compensate 
for occupational accidents.

 
> Dave:
> Isn't "allowing to forcibly take" a contradiction?


JW:
One would think so, wouldn't one?  So strike "allowing to."  From 
whom would someone try to forceably take blood? Snape? Any Malfoy?
> 
> 
> Dave:
> If Voldemort
> regenerating his body is so complicated, I imagine
> encasing a soul requires an equally elaborate ritual.  I'm even
> wondering if Harry might be forced to witness at least part of it
> before this saga is over...


JW:
I have no idea why HP would need to witness the encasement of a 
soul.  However, he DID participate in LV's re-embodiment, and with 
help from Ron & Hermione could probably perform it.

However, I agree that there are huge holes and inconsistencies in 
Harry Arisen's variation on the "unintentional horcrux" hypothesis.  
However, let's give him a chance to support it with canonical facts.  
I am curious to see if he can develope his conjecture into a theory.