[HPforGrownups] Re: Who was responsible for Sirius' death?

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 167820

Nikkalmati
 
I think we also can consider that SS did not advise Black to stay at GP to
be safe.  He told him to wait for DD so he could fill him in on  things.
Then presumably SB could come with DD to save Harry.  SB  unreasonably and
recklessly ignored that order or advice and came with the  Order members,
leaving DD to arrive at an empty house and requiring that he take  the time
to question Kreacher, thus, delaying DD's own arrival at the MOM.
 
Nikkalmati 
 


Sherry:

Would any parent sit around and wait for someone else when there child is in
danger?  I think not.  To me, Sirius acted like any parental figure would
have acted.  He was a damn fool for taunting Bellatrix and not taking her
seriously in the duel, but he wasn't wrong for rushing off to try to help
Harry in the first place.  in my opinion, anyway.  He was just being
parental.

Sherry