Who was responsible for Sirius' death?

[Dana]

No: HPFGUIDX 167842

> Nikkalmati
>  
> I think we also can consider that SS did not advise Black to stay 
> at GP to  be safe.  He told him to wait for DD so he could fill him 
> in on  things.  Then presumably SB could come with DD to save 
> Harry. SB  unreasonably and recklessly ignored that order or advice 
> and came with the  Order members, leaving DD to arrive at an empty 
> house and requiring that he take  the time to question Kreacher, 
> thus, delaying DD's own arrival at the MOM.

Dana:
No other Order Member seemed to think someone needed to stay behind to 
inform DD either. They all seemed to agree to leave it up to Kreacher. 
It is interesting to blame Sirius for that, while there where other 
Order Members present as well. It wasn't just Sirius call. Just because 
they couldn't make Sirius stay behind, when his Godson was in danger, 
doesn't mean no one else could have made the choice to wait for DD. It 
seems that all Order Members thought it more important to go right 
away, do you consider them reckless or unreasonable too? All of them 
rushed out prepared to risk their life's. And accoording to many, Snape 
could not know, Sirius was at risk of dying, so then his request for 
Sirius to stay behind could not be related to keeping him safe either. 
JMHO 

Dana