Snape name mentioned in OOP

zanooda2 zanooda2 at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 22 23:05:47 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 167852

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dumbledore11214" 
<dumbledore11214 at ...> wrote:

> > zanooda:

> > You probably mean the meeting that was going on when Harry and 
> > the  Advance Guard arrived to 12 GP.  
 
> Alla:
 
> Oh, but this is the same meeting that Zara quoted, no? I don't 
> know. Maybe I was thinking about it and the fact that there is a 
> short time difference in between in my mind made it possible that 
> it was not Snape. I mean, I agree with you - it is logical to 
> assume that it was Snape, but I keep hoping that somebody else 
> appeared in between as well.

zanooda:

I was not following that thread, sorry, so I don't know what you guys 
were talking about. I suppose "my" meeting is same as Zara's though, 
because it is the only one in the book :-). As for the possibility 
that "he" is not Snape, I just don't know. Theoretically it's 
possible, of course, but it seems a bit of a stretch to me. 

Besides, even if DD has some other spy among DEs, I doubt that this 
spy will just show up at GP. Snape comes there and gives reports 
because he is a double agent. His both "masters" know that he must 
interact with the other side and give the other side some information 
(or desinformation). DD's "other spy" would be too precious to show 
to all the Order members, that would be a terrible risk for him, IMO. 
He would contact DD and DD alone, and not give reports to everybody, 
including Mungungus :-).


> Alla: 

> You know I so dislike that I am so less versed in OOP details than 
> other books for discussion purposes, but still won't reread the 
> book completely, only bits and pieces as needed sometimes. Heeeee. 
> Hate so many more things in that book than love. 

zanooda:

Well, you'll know then whom to ask questions next time, because I 
love OotP and read it often :-).


> Alla:

> there is also Umbridge and Sirius' death and that ugly speech of DD
 

zanooda:

But there is also Luna, and DA, and F&G's fireworks...
 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive