Crookshank

[mueckelein]

No: HPFGUIDX 167944

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Akash aki <akash2006k at ...> wrote:

> Listening all the creative ideas encourage me that I should also
> start thinking ( :p).

> Then it struck me ...
> "What if Crookshank is animagus....and who else than the most wanted
> RAB itself ! ! !"
>
> Nobody have seen or confirmed about RAB ( in case he is another
> Black) being murdered by Tom. It may be just like Pettigrew he also
> bidding his time.

muecklein:
> Hi, according to JKR Crookshank is a halfkneazle, whatever that is,
> and he is definitely not an animagus. RAB is most certainly Regulus
> Black, who was killed around Harry´s birthday. Since in other
> languages Regulus Black has a different name and the letters RAB are
> changed so that the letters match Sirius´brother´s name again, I
> would say it definitely is Regulus Black.

muecklein