Requiescat in Pace: Unforgivables

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 174654

> colebiancardi:
> 
> yes, it WAS wrong for Snape to use the AK.  I still have not seen 
any
> resolution, via canon, that he actually used the AK on DD.  Remember
> all the threads on Snape & the AK prior to DH's?  I tried to bring 
it
> up the other day, if anyone had found canon in DH's that it was a 
true
> AK that Snape used, and not a non-verbal spell masked as an AK.
<SNIP>


Alla:

Ok, we agree that it is wrong then :)

But on the second point, I think it is up to you ( hypotheticall you, 
anybody who brings up that this is not AK) to prove that it was not, 
no?

Canon says it was AK. I believe that it was AK. Unless there is an 
evidence that **it was not one** of course. That's my take on things 
anyways.

I mean, how can you prove the negative? You argue that it was not AK, 
contrary to canon saying so IMO, so I say it is up to you to provide  
the evidence ;)


JMO,

Alla