The Joke's on Me

[Mike]

No: HPFGUIDX 174876

> Potioncat
> 
> Did anyone outsmart themselves in DH? The time you knew at once 
> what was going on and what was about to happen
. But to your 
> surprise, it didn't? Not a disappointing moment, but a groaner 
> moment that made you laugh at yourself. Maybe even a place where 
> you half suspected JKR had just pulled one over on you.
> <snip>

Mike:
Hi PC :) My moment came when they were all arriving at the Weasleys 
after the 7 Harry's left 4 Privet Dr. Lupin made this big show of 
confirming Harry et al were really themselves with all these personal 
questions. Now, I'm thinking JKR is setting us up for a traitor in 
the Order.

Next thing I notice, Tonks arrives, and nobody asks her any personal 
questions. I'm jumping up and down, yelling at Lupin, "Tonks, hey 
what about Tonks, c'mon Remus you clod, ask her a question, she's 
your wife and a metamorphmagus, she doesn't even have to look the 
same." 

Somehow, I morphed this into believing that this is the clue that 
Tonks is the turncoat. So I'm waiting ..... and waiting .... and 
finally we see her at the beginning of the Battle of Hogwarts seeming 
kind of off. So I'm waiting again,... nothing, she even dies off 
stage. ::throws hands up in the air::

Oh yeah, I'm brilliant. <he says sarcastically>

Mike, who did get more predictions right than wrong, so he felt 
doubly good after reading DH :D