Another Timeline Problem

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 174926

mz_annethrope:
" So I think everything is 
chronological here. It just means that Snape must have entered 12 GP 
after Moody died so he got by the trap Moody set for him."


Unfortunately, JKR in her online chat, or one of the interviews after publication of DH, said Snape went to 12 GP immediately after DD's death.  Moody had not yet set the charms.  That one memory is out of sequence by two or three memories (it should occur 2-3 before it does).

CathyD

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]