[HPforGrownups] Dumbledore and the slaughtered pig

[Kemper]

No: HPFGUIDX 175111

> "va32h" Wrote:
>
>  > I can think of a very good reason for
>  > Dumbledore to lie to Snape. Dumbledore
>  > knows that Harry loathes Snape - why on
>  > earth would Harry just believe Snape if
>  > Snape merely told Harry what Dumbledore
>  > said? […] Snape is going to have to
>  > provide some kind of proof.

>  eggplant:
>  If what you say is correct and "Showing Harry a memory
>  seems the best way to prove that what Snape is saying is true" then
>  why on Earth show him a memory of Snape's, a memory of Dumbledore
>  flapping him gums? Why didn't Dumbledore give Snape a bottle
>  containing a memory of his own and tell him to give it to Harry when
>  the time was right?

Kemper now:
I think it would be unsafe to have Dumbledore's memories bottled up.
It's a security risk.

Kemper, feeling like he should write more but up for 27 hours and
wants to sleep but neighbors are being noisy mowing lawns, cutting
down trees, and other din