Seen or Unseen - Time turning

[bgrugin]

No: HPFGUIDX 176206

> > > > ***Katie:
> > > <snip>
> > > > So, basically, a plot device, but a well-supported one, 
> > > > seeing as it was very clear that H/H from the future 
> > > > "cannot be seen!!", according to Dumbledore. 
> 
> Mike:
> Watch your step here Dale, big plot hole ahead. Because as soon as 
> Dumbledore said that to Hermione she should have said, 'What are 
you 
> talking about, what law? I've been using this thing all year to get 
> to my classes, of course I've been seen while I was time-turned.' 

MusicalBetsy here:
Maybe in her situation it's okay for others to see the time-turned 
Hermione AS LONG AS no one sees BOTH Hermiones at the same time.  
After all, that would make anyone wonder what the heck was going on.  
This is just a guess, BTW.


> But Dale's question begs another. How come Lupin didn't see TTed 
> Harry and Hermione on the Marauder's Map? He said he was watching 
> the Trio and even guessed they were under James' cloak. So when 
TTed 
> and non-TTed almost ran into each other in the entrance hall, why 
> doesn't Lupin see two Harry and two Hermione dots?. 
> 
> Mike
>

MusicalBetsy again:
Okay, another guess.  Maybe the Marauder's Map doesn't pick up time 
turned people?  Possibly?  Maybe?  Cause it's the only explanation 
that works??

MusicalBetsy, just trying to fix any plot holes so she can go back to 
enjoying the books without anything getting in her way...