[HPforGrownups] Another inconsistency?

Sharon Hayes s.hayes at qut.edu.au
Wed Aug 29 23:02:02 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 176426


>   Sharon:
>   <snipping>
>   So neither Ron nor Harry had a lisence to Apparate.
>   Yet in DH, we see them both Apparating all over the
>   place. We know Harry didn't go for his lisence
>   becuase he left on the quest for Horcruxes almost as
>   soon as he turned seventeen. Maybe Ron did go for
>   his test as some
>   stage, but we never hear about it. My take is that,
>   in the uproar
>   surrounding Voldemort taking over the MOM and
>   Hogwarts, etc, that the MOM wasn't being too rigid
>   about rules.
>
>   Monica:
>
>   I believe that Hermione was actually doing side
>   along apparition to take the 2 of them with her
>   where she went, which is how they all ended up in
>   the same forest when the deatheater apperated with
>   them to #12 grimmauld place.

Sharon again:
But Ron and Harry apparate separately to Shell Cottage from the Malfoy Manor, 
and Ron apparates a few times trying to come back after he walked out on Harry 
and Hermione. It's such a minor detail, but it's one of those niggly things I just 
wonder about.  What happens if you apparate without a license (Think I spelt it 
right this time. LOL)




More information about the HPforGrownups archive