Another inconsistency?

Tom Cogburn tomcogburn at earthlink.net
Thu Aug 30 08:30:42 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 176443

I believe the issue isn't apparating without a license, but that
because they were all three of age, they were allowed to practice magic
without fear of being monitored by the Ministry of Magic.  Throughout
the whole series, wizards and witches were doing all kinds of "illegal
magic" but weren't punished until their acts were discovered and they
had been tried.  It's not like a bell rang everytime someone cast a
dark spell.  No one at the Ministry would have any idea that "illegal
magic" was taking place unless someone turned the offending
wizard/witch in.


Tom




More information about the HPforGrownups archive