Snape and Dumbledore on the Tower/ He cant find all four Horkeys in just one book.
ginger mabayoje
funkeginger at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 27 09:15:19 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 165494
I don't think that Snape is really bad or that he killed DD on the tower like we think he did. I think that Snape knew that if he lived after drinking that potion, if DD was not killed soon that somehow You Know Who would find out.
I also think that Snape will help Harry in the end to kill You Know Who.
Do you guys think that this is the last book? I don't, I don't think that everything can be done in one book. For the following reasons:
One Harry can't find all four Horcruxes in just one book and kill the seven pieces of V soul, it can't be done. The Deathly Hallows is only going to be about 780 pages or anyway JKR does not pass that number of pages.
How can she just jam everything together and just be done? I want to see what happens to Harry and Ron an Hogwarts after they kill You Know Who.
It will take him a long time to find the Horcruxes, look how long DD was looking for them, give or take five years.
He needs some help with his fighting skills, he can't take on V with just the disarming spell and the half-blood spell, he needs a lot of help to be able to fight V. Look how V and DD were fighting in book five. They had real skills.
He also needs more skills to find those Horcruxes. Look what happened to DD. He was one of the most powerful wizards and he was really weakened by that poison. If DD did not drink that stuff Snape would never have been able to kill him.
Last but not least, I don't think everything could just add up in one book like who is RAB and why did DD trust Snape so much. And would like to still find out what happens when people go through the Veil.
funkeginger
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive