Expressing a Sentiment about the Series
Goddlefrood
gav_fiji at yahoo.com
Mon Jul 9 11:05:49 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 171463
Goddlefrood:
Now that the final book is about to be released there are
increasing numbers of articles in newspapers, online journals,
blogs, etc. relative to book 7. Whatever anyone here may
speculate the book series will come to an end. Or will it?
At the risk of being bombarded with leftover steak and kidney
pie I write the below in counter to a proposed petition I
noted in a recent newspaper piece. Ayes to the right, might
I suggest? Nays to the left, as is your privilege.
Dear Joanne Rowling,
I am and have been a keen and avid reader of your series of
novels following the adventures of Harry Potter. They are
a tremendous and fulfilling read. Your characterisations
are fabulous, your way of keeping we readers guessing over
certain characters' loyalties keep us turning the pages
and I have no doubt that by the time I have finished reading
the final installment I will be more than satisfied with the
way you have chosen to end your story.
Earlier today I came across a story saying that you should
continue the series post-Deathly Hallows. It purports to
express the sentiment of a number of your fans. There is
a call for a petition of a million online signatures, and
I, like the writer of that piece, have no doubt that many
will sign the same. This petition will be asking you not
to stop at Deathly Hallows. Please ignore it, even if there
are 100 million signatories. You have stated that Harry's
story will come to an end and that all back story necessary
to complete the tale will be contained in book 7. I believe
you, and have faith in your ability to wrap up Harry's journey
to the lasting gratification of your fans.
You do not strike me, and I hope many millions of others,
as someone who would buckle under pressure to continue
writing about Harry Potter and / or his world. If your
various publishers are displeased that there will be no
further books about this world then ignore them. You will
find another publisher if you choose to continue writing
other things, and I hope you do. The film industry be hanged
too, they should have plenty of material in existing yet to
be filmed works, and, dare I hope, original ideas not based
on fiction to keep them going for decades, if not centuries.
Once you are satisfied with Harry's chronicle that should be
good enough. You have added hugely to the enjoyment of reading
for millions of people, but ultimately, as you have said, it
is your story and you wrote it for yourself. Any further books
on the world may just spoil the effect you have created with
this series. Perhaps peripheral books may be fine; I urge you
not to condescend to write further tales of Harry or his world
unless you want to.
I remain your faithful reader,
Goddlefrood
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive