Faith Predictions
drax_orion
Adam.Chase at charter.net
Sat Jul 14 04:58:36 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 171718
> > Neri :
> > The green potion from the cave didn't have any additional
> > effects beside those stated by Dumbledore: weakening the drinker
> > and trying to prevent him from taking the Horcrux by any way
> > possible.
>
> > Catlady:
> > So what was that bad dream he was re-living?
> >
>
> Neri:
> Where's the canon that he was re-living anything? A bad dream can
> be all hallucination, can't it. I don't know any canon that anything
> Dumbledore was talking about during his potion experience had
> actually happened before, and Dumbledore's canon explanation of the
> potion's effect is perfectly adequate. In fact it is considerably
> more adequate than the OotP explanation of the bubblegum wrappers,
> and yet before HBP Faith had no trouble predicting that all the
> grand bubblegum wrappers theories are headed straight for the
> bottom of the Bay.
Drax:
Whats this about bubblegum?
Anyways I agree about the hallucination stuff. Most likely the potion
induced the same effects as his ministrations on the 2 kids he brought
down there when he lived at the orphanage.
A thought just occured to me. What if that basin full of potion was
something in place from long ago and Voldie simply discovered it. He
could have tormented the 2 kids by making them drink the potion.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive