epilogue

Jo twirliewirlie85 at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 24 21:24:10 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172287

luis padilla <morpheo00924@ wrote:

spoiler

spoiler


spoiler


spoiler


spoiler

Luis:
Is it just me or Lupin's son should'nt have been at the Hogwart 
Express? I mean, that scene was 19 years after Voldemort's death and 
Lupin's son was already born at that moment, so he should be 19 years 
old in the epilogue, therefore having no business been at the train 
at that moment.

JO writes:

Page 605 Hp & DH UK hardback version:

James had reappeared; he had divested himself of his trunk, owl and 
trolley, and was evidently bursting with news.  
"Teddy's back there," he said breathlessly, pointing back over his 
shoulder into the billowing clouds of steam.  "Just seen him!  And 
guess what he's doing?  Snogging Victoire!"

Snip of text....

"....he said he's come to see her off!  And then he told me to go 
away.  He's snogging her!"

That says to me that Ted Lupin had come to see Victoire off as she 
left for school, not that he was catching the train himself.

Jo.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive