DH rambles and crows eating _ LOVEd this book

[hickengruendler]

No: HPFGUIDX 172416

 
> Alla:
> 
> 
> 
> I give him a credit for doing a right thing for the sake of Lily, 
> NOT for the sake of saving the world, but that is surely more than 
I 
> wanted to give him credit for, Anything else? 
> 
> I am also forced to credit him for some change over the 
> years, I guess, but I have  lot of doubt that he would ever come to 
> the right side if Voldemort would have agreed to spare Lily.
> 
> 
> 
> He bargained with Voldemort first. The words "you disgust me" 
summed 
> it up for me quite well.
 
Hickengruendler:


But Voldemort did agree to spare Lily. "Step aside you silly girl." 
Snape went to Dumbledore nonetheless, probably because he didn't 
trust Voldemort (understandably so). So, yes, in the beginning 
Snape's motivations were entirely selfish. There's just that one 
Muggleborn, he always made an exception for, and he did this time as 
well. Sure it is disgusting, how less he cared about Harry (or for 
that matter, the Longbottom family). But it did grow into more, over 
the years. And since you weren't the only one, who read the epilogue 
first, (I did as well *g*), I have to say, that I felt incredibily 
sorry for him in the first chapter, where the Muggle studies teacher 
got killed.

His deaths cene I found very good, really. Mostly because it wasn't 
the big sacrific emost people seem to have expected.

And quite aside from Snape, and because I don't want to waste too 
many posts for today, I have to say that I loved Neville. My 
goodness, wa she awesome.