comments and questions

pwrmom2 jenlundq at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 25 14:12:55 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 172661

Pwrmom2:
   First of all, I didn't read all of the replies about the crying
creature at Kingscross, so if this was already stated, please
forgive me, but IMO I don't think it was just the part of Vodie's
soul that was in Harry, but probably all of the pieces from all of
the Horocrux's destroyed up to that point...just waiting for the one
last peace so it could go on to it's final miserable station in the
end (WW equivalent of He-- I assume).

   Also, are we just going to assume Neville got the sword because
there was a dire need and he was lucky enough to get it presumably
from the Sorting Hat before Voldemort got it?  That part still
confuses me a little bit.

  Lastly, I noticed someone early on commenting on why was Teddy at
the train station if he was 19 years old.  IMO he was there just
to "snog" on Bill's daughter before she heads off to what I am going
to assume is her last year at Hogwarts.

   Someone else commented on Ron's comment about grandpa Weasley
disowning a member of the family marrying a pureblood as irony
because Weasley's are a pure blood line.  This may be true, but look
what the 3 kids we know of married.  Ron married Hermione.  Yes
she's a witch, but she's a mudblood, not pureblood.  Ginny married
Harry, his mother was a mudblood (I know I'm using the horrible
word, but it is for quickness of typing) and Bill married a Veela
or whatever Fleur is (or 1/2, I think, not full blood).  Anyway,
track record so far is no pure bloods.  Granted we don't know who or
if George or Percy married, but I think I made my point.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive