[HPforGrownups] Re: inconsistency?

[Kim]

No: HPFGUIDX 172742

Lindsay" <frithar at ...> wrote:
>
> Still catching up on all posts-- forgive if this is a repeat,
> but how on earth did DD beat Grindelwald in the duel if Gr had
> an _unbeatable_ wand??? Isn't that what they say the whole point
> was of the elder wand: It can't be eaten in a duel?


Kim:

Grindelwald was not the true master of the Elder wand, because he did not win it, he stole it.  So, it was not all powerful for him.  Just like it was not all powerful for Voldemort.   I'm still trying to figure out how it became Dumbledore's true wand.  I'm sure he won it from Grindelwald, but since Grindelwald stole it, things can't be that simple.

Kim