LONG collection of DH related thoughts.

[rowena_grunnionffitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 173092

> > Joe:
> > Snape/Pensieve - Remember, we are only seeing what Snape wanted
> > Harry to see. This is Snape's edited version of things. Yes, a
> > pensieve shows only true things, but it doesn't show EVERYTHING. It
> > doesn't show what we might call "refuting evidence."

rowena_grunnioffitch:
Excuse me? Slughorn's attempt at falsification shows how impossible
undetectable editing is and exactly how much control did a dying Snape
have?  Personally I think he gave Harry a little more than he meant to.
Just as well he didn't survive, he'd have died of the humiliation of
Harry knowing all.  Besides, the fact that pensieve scenes are *NOT*
from the subject's pov suggests a degree of objectivity.