Fenrir's Dark mark (was Re: Another inconsistency?)

Cyril A Fernandes caaf at hotmail.com
Fri Jul 27 12:52:55 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 173223

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, career advisor <aceworker at ...> 
wrote:

Cyril here:

>
> Toner wrote:
> 
> > I thought Fenrir had a dark mark?
> >
> > During the tower scene at the end of HBP, a group of DEs join DD,
> > Harry and Draco up on the top of the tower, and the rest of the 
OotP
> > can't get up the stairs due to some magical wall except for 
Snape. At
> > the time, the reasoning for this was that only people with Dark 
Marks
> > could go through the invisible wall.
> >
> > However, in DH, Fenrir cannot enter the Malfoy Manor, even 
though it
> > appeared you needed a Dark Mark to go through the gate (like 
Snape and
> > Amycus in the first chapter).
>    
>   The Dark Mark is just a spell isn't it. Which means it can be 
removed. If Voldy needed Fenrir to have a Dark Mark for a specefic 
mission, he can give him one, no problem and then remove it latter. 
What happended to Mos Morde in this book anyway. The Dark Mark 
wasn;t cast into the sky once this entire book, not even during the 
final battle.  
> 
>        

Cyril:

Well, from what I remember of that scene on top of the tower, some 
had made it up, and the barrier was probably cast afterwards. So 
Fenrir was probably on the other side of the barrier, and did not 
need to go through it.

Cyril - trying to read hundreds of posts nearly as quickly as he 
read DH.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive