my DH reactions minus Snape

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 173359

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "prep0strus" <prep0strus at ...> 
wrote:

> The besting in a duel, I'm sorry to say, still baffles me

Do you mean DD besting Grindelwald? I don't think that the Elder wand 
was really invincible, just very powerful. DD won because of his 
superior skill, IMO. I think DD was right when he suggested that the 
Hallows were man-made objects, just imbued with very powerful magic. 
This means for me that Harry was never immortal, even when he owned all 
three Hallows.


> What truly transfers ownership of the elder wand, and why was Harry 
> able to take mastery from Draco, but Voldy didn't get it from Harry 
> when he blasted him?


But Harry didn't die, right? We can't even say that he was defeated, 
because he didn't fight, he "died" willingly, undefeated. It was his 
own decision to die, and it was more like suicide then anything else.

zanooda