Rebounding curses (WAS Re:replies to 1000 posts)

[doug rogers]

No: HPFGUIDX 173883

Bex:
I believe that Moldy Shorts felt that Horcrux being destroyed (Harry's
piece of Voldy soul) - I think the reason he felt it is that he did it
to himself.

doug:
Reasonable enough, but why would Voldemort's AK in the woods  
necessarily kill the 'horcrux' soul and not Harry's? I believe it is  
the 'death' of the container which allows the separation and passing on…

…so does Avada Kadavra expel the soul rather than the life force?  
Seemingly, in this instance.

…de-horcruxing requires the destruction, or 'death' of the  
container... so Harry must have died (?) or was destroyed in some way  
(?).

There is just too much deux ex machina.


___<http://home.golden.net/~samu>
__<http://dougsamu.wordpress.com/>