Prank and various responsibilities WAS: Re: Marietta

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 169663

 
> Dana before:
> Because canon does not imply that Snape was tricked into going there by 
> the people telling the story, it is only Snape that relays the story in 
> that way. 
> 
> Dana now:
> Before everyone starts falling over me I should correct that Lupin 
> called it a trick too. Which still did not take Snape's free choice in 
> my opinion but just to be fair he did state it. 
> 

colebiancardi:

sure Snape had free will; so did Sirius when he set Snape up.  So did
James when he saved Snape's life.  Sirius DID mean for harm to come to
Snape;  James recognized it and Lupin did as well - Lupin thought it
was not Sirius's shining moment there.

It was a trick;  Snape told the truth there; Lupin backed him up.  

colebiancardi