[HPforGrownups] Prank and various responsibilities WAS: Re: Marietta

[sistermagpie]

No: HPFGUIDX 169706

Alla:

And still in PoA Snape goes to the Shack knowing that he may face a 
werewolf, does he not? I think Snape will be very happy to kill a 
werewolf or two. Just **speculating** here of course.

As to nobody in canon ever suggested that situation - eh, of course 
they did not, if it meant to be a surprise in book 7 IMO. And I do 
not believe that it will take a lot of effort to change the picture 
we have now with the missing information and all that. 

But for the record if it is true, the speculation, I do not believe 
Marauders knew that Snape figured it out. I think he decided to 
outsmart them and go. So, Sirius responsibility is still there, 
really.

Of course Snape dear becomes even more disgusting if that 
**speculation** is true.

But of course it may not be true. It is after all just speculation.


Magpie:
Okay--I see what you mean, particularly with Sirius not knowing that Snape
knew. The two questions that brings up for me, though, is that a) Snape
still seems genuinely angry about Sirius "trying to kill" him. Now, I
assume you could say he's lying or just angry on principle. 

But the problem is b) which is that if Snape was going into the tunnel
knowing he was meeting a werewolf because he wanted to kill Lupin as a
werewolf, then I have a hard time finding a way Snape would think James
saved his life. I think he would consider James to have saved Lupin's life,
not Snape's.

-m