Petunia's Eyes

[karen]

No: HPFGUIDX 169810

Anne's post has got me thinking now...

"Wait, wait, wait. This just occurred to me as I was writing this
post. Maybe S. R. is absolutely correct. Maybe point no. 1 is not
true. Maybe Lily and Petunia aren't sisters by blood after all. 
Maybe one or the other was indeed adopted."

Ok so Lily and Petunia are not sisters- let's take the leap and make 
that statement.  Petunia seems to hate HP quite a bit and seems really 
jealous in PS/SS when she talks about how her sister was a witch and 
her parents were so proud to have a witch in the family.  She also 
seems so jealous of Harry throughout the books too, part of the many 
reasons why she may treat him badly.  What if she relates to Harry and 
is jealous of him because she came from a similiar situation?  What if 
she was an orphan or what if her parents left her and Lily's parents 
took her in because they had a little girl close to her age...  What 
are your thoughts on this?