Petunia's Eyes

[ronnie]

No: HPFGUIDX 169932

---> Anne Squires:
> 
> 1.  She has to be related by blood or no blood protection.
> 2.  Her eyes are not like her sister's. 
> 3.  JKR said, "She is not a squib, although that is a very good 
guess. 
> Oh, I am giving a lot away here. I am being shockingly indiscreet."  
> 
> If she's not a squib (but, that's a good guess), and she's not a
> witch, then she's....what? A Muggle, right?  What's surprising about

What's wrong with you people? of course she's Lilly's sister! DD 
couldn't be wrong there - your adoption theory seems very far fetched 
to me...

However, who said she's not a witch? 
mayby Petunia was so shocked or scared of discovering her magic 
abilities in the midst of a muggle family, that she was the first 
victim of her policy to  "squash out all of the magic" from her. 
To me Petunia seems an extremely anxious person - full of fears and 
repressions. Her cleaning certainly indicates an OCD tendency.... 
maybe the reason for her severe anxiety is exactly the fear of the 
magic within her... 
Besides, I think JK hinted that someone known as a muggle will do some 
magic in book 7 - I really believe it could be Petunia (perhaps Dudley 
will be in danger).