Neither Harry nor his Scar is a Horcrux (Was Re: Voldemort's Age)

[Neri]

No: HPFGUIDX 170279

 
> Pippin:
> <snip>
> Snape says that Bella is familiar with the magic that hides
> the Order's headquarters. We are reminded in The Other 
> Minister that both sides have similar magical capabilities. 
> Isn't it likely that Voldemort is secret keeper for the Death
> Eaters just as Dumbledore was secret keeper for the Order?
> 
> And where is the Secret Keeper's secret hidden? 
> Why, in the *soul* of the Secret Keeper. What
> if on the night he gave Harry that scar, Voldemort
> transferred not only his powers but his secrets to Harry?
> 


Neri:
I think this is a brilliant idea, but I see some difficulties with it.
What is the secret that Voldemort had hidden in his own soul? The
location of the DEs HQ? Why would that be such an important secret?
Wouldn't it be more logical to hide the secret of the locations of the
Horcruxes themselves? Yet it seems that this secret isn't protected by
a Fidelius, or Dumbledore would be unable to find the ring and RAB
would be unable to find the locket. 

If some secret is hidden in Voldemort's soul, then it must be the most
important secret of all. What would be even more important than the
location of the Horcruxes?


Neri