Justice to Snape WAS: Re: Werewolves? There Wolves!

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 170608


> Carol, who thinks that Snape, though wrong about the murderer and his
> accomplice, was right that the werewolf was deadly and really did save
> their lives
> 
> Mike:
> I'm thinking time-turned Harry and Hermione would disagree with this 
> assessment. Had they all left Snape tied up in the Shack, wandless, 
> I'm betting these two could have rescued their unconscious alter 
> selves and Ron and Sirius.

Pippin:

 Harry and Hermione don't seem to agree:

"Hermione!" said Harry suddenly. "We've got to move!"
"We mustn't, I keep telling you--"
"Not to interfere! Lupin's going to run into the forest, right at us!"
Hermione gasped.

They're not at all confident of their ability to handle a werewolf,
either here or earlier when Sirius fought Lupin for them. Harry
stood frozen, for once unable to move when a friend was in danger. 


> Mike:
> As I've posted before, no amount of remorse will bring back Harry's 
> parents. And Harry shouldn't and won't, imo, ever get past this basic 
> truth. No matter what Snape does to redeem himself. 


Pippin:
And no amount of punishment will bring them back either. 

Pippin