And in The End...CoS

[Akash aki]

No: HPFGUIDX 165766

First of all, very nice points..... I am trying to make personal responses for your doubts...I don't claim anything.....

cdayr <cdayr at yahoo.com> wrote the questions:

1. Dobby and the House Elves:

We saw it in CoS that elves are far more powerful magical creatures than wizards.  As the important and powerful characters from the Order side are dying or not available somehow, finally they will come to act, it's kinda war of good and evil, either you are on good or on evil side, no one can be neutral.

Next, it's attitude, most of time most of the people felt proud of their powerful supremes, they can be masters, bosses, companions, rulers...anything.  It is very difficult, but not impossible because then there would be no revolution by suppressed or slaves or such.  That makes Dobby hate his masters.

2. Voldemort entrusted...

Nah, he didn't trust Malfoy, but he was securing it for the future use, as was evidenced.  No one knew about the Horcrux at that time, when Voldy went to play biggest gamble against the prophecy.  He took measures if things got beyond control and put one of his parts in such hands so as to make it possible to survive again.

I guess when he feels there is any danger to his life, he makes sure that his Horcrux is in such condition so that he again may come back.

3. Deathday party

I guess yes.... there must be some clue.  As in if you are not completely chopped off you can not join headless regime.  She must have some point there which relates similarly to Horcruxes and other cases.

4. Chamber of  "Secrets"?

I guess no, not some significant secret. But there may be a return back to COS.

5. The Dueling Club

Assuming Snape is not incarnation of devil, it is possible he tried to prevent the fact that HP can speak Parseltongue.  Just assume he is with DD and here things settle well.

6. The Hormorphus Charm: Hope for Remus and Bill?

For sure.

7. "What do you think would have happened if Riddle had escaped from the diary by stealing Ginny's soul?"

He is a far more powerful wizard than others, is even Minister of Magic.  Don't see Gin as girlfriend of HP, HP is a prophecy not Ginny.  No one other than DD is there who doesn't fear him or who dares to challenge him. I think it's not a question "did he know about 'Diary destroyed'".

8. Selfishly
old theories on Aragog

Strangely, I read only e-mails. So I'm ashamed and sorry for this.


9. Uniquely CoS

Sorry too tired to answer :p.  But I do think they have some minor but important roles to play.

10. Too much already,

I agree, and glad you realise, :p.  Yeah HP is not a Horcrux but he does have some of the powers ( it's powers not parts) of Voldy the bad.

  regards
  avi_._,_.___