[HPforGrownups] Re: HP's last hope for disarming the Horcrux and battle

[ginger mabayoje]

No: HPFGUIDX 165883

> Funkeginger:
> 
> Most people are saying that Harry's last hope for 
> fighting You Know Who and disarming the Horcruxes is
> Bill. I don't get it, where in all the books does it
> say that Bill is skilled in the Dark Arts enough to 
> teach HP how to fight Voldemort?
> 
> ...

bboyminn:

> Others have already answered, but hopefully I can 
elaborate a bit. First no one is saying Bill's role is
pivotal or all inclusive. Bil has a specialty, and that
is curse breaking, not just general curse breaking but
breaking curses made in languages that are long dead or 
languages that he doesn't specifically understand.

<snip>
Each of the Order members and each of the key people 
in Harry's life has specialized talents. < 
<snip>

Funkeginger:

  I get what you are saying that there are different members in the order with different skills that will more than likley help Harry.

bboyminn:

  <Each of the Order members and each of the key people 
in Harry's life has specialized talents. Harry will
resist using the people at first because he has made
a promise to Dumbledore not to tell people what he
is doing. Then he will realize, probably with Ron and
Hermione's help, that he can enlist the help of these
talented people without telling them everything. >

   But just because Bill is a  curse breaker does not mean that he is trained to handle Voldemort's Horcrux traps like that stuff in the cave.
   It's like saying that a nurse working with a doctor all day in the hospital is Qualified to do operations if a patient is dying and there are no doctors around.
   She or he's not best what for the doctor. That's what I am saying with Bill . He might work with Curses every day but I doubt that they are half as dangerous as Voldemort's Horcrux traps.

   You have to take in to account that Eygptians just wanted to keep people out with their traps, not really kill them or drive them mad and curse them on told pain before killing them.

   Voldemort does, and it use a bit of logic. It's better to die a quick and painful death then, be driven mad by a curse and be caused so much pain like DD was. I was really surprised Snape that killed him it was the Poison. 
   
Do you think that Bill just because of his job can handle what DD could not?
   I thing you are right in the sense that it is only the order that can help him from this point. Unless we find out that Snape is not bad or Sirius and DD really are not dead. 

Funkeginger