Dumbledore's judgment (WAS Hermione and 'Evil is a strong word')

[a_svirn]

No: HPFGUIDX 166021

> Magpie:
<snip> Could he be suckered in by a fake 
> tale of remorse? That's the type of thing Dumbledore doesn't seem 
to fall 
> for. Even when he's got fakes in the school like Fake!Moody and 
Lockhart it 
> doesn't seem like Dumbledore's being played as gullible about their 
> character. With Moody he's basing his judgment on actual Moody. 
Carol 
> brought up Draco as someone who doesn't trust Dumbledore's judgment 
but I'd 
> also add him under the list of people Dumbledore seems to get once 
he sets 
> his mind to him. 
<snip>

a_svirn:
Well, actually, we know of at least two people who definitely didn't 
trust in Dumbledore's judgement – James and Sirius. Though I am 
compelled to admit that they are both dead now, because their own 
judgment had proved to be even faultier.