Perjury, Dumbledore, and Right v Easy once Again (Re: Percy.)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 166158

"justcarol67" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:

> Fudge announces the "disciplinary hearing"(not trial, BTW) 

Fudge calls it a disciplinary hearing, Dumbledore calls it a full
criminal trial. Who are you going to believe, fudge or Dumbledore? So
let's review, Harry (twice!) thinks about being sentenced to Azkaban,
AFTER that we learn it is a full criminal trial and he is being judged
by the full Wizengamot, something that is very rare; and yet you think
JKR expects her readers to believe Harry's fears were overblown and
the thought of Harry going to Azkaban never entered Percy's head. I
don't buy it.   

> Percy, of course, simply takes notes. Fudge 

Yes, he was just following orders, but I would maintain it's imposable
to read that chapter and not know exactly what side Percy is on. The
man is evil.

Eggplant