Musing on Buckbeak/ Some Croockshanks and Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 166239

> colebiancardi(taking the other side now ;) )
> 
> well, my take on it is that Buckbeak was trying to defend Harry, who
> was under attack from someone else - he chased Snape because Snape 
was
> the closest one to Harry.  
> 
> However, Crookshanks has never behaved in an ill-manner towards Snape
> - we never see it and Crookshanks does live at Hogwarts & roams 
freely
> around the grounds.   
>


Alla:

Oh, of course Buckbeak attacks because Harry is his friend as well ( 
nods to Ceridwen as well :)).

I just believe that he also recognised that his friend was attacked by 
bad person, hehe.

Interesting about Croockshanks never behaving in ill manner towards 
Snape, actually. I am not sure if that was ever mentioned that 
Croockshanks came to be in close proximity with Snape, or did he?

I mean, Croockshanks would only react if bad person is close by, did 
he not?