[HPforGrownups] Re: Musing on Buckbeak/ Some Croockshanks and Snape

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 166240

Alla:
Interesting about Croockshanks never behaving in ill manner towards Snape,
actually. I am not sure if that was ever mentioned that Croockshanks came to
be in close proximity with Snape, or did he?

I mean, Croockshanks would only react if bad person is close by, did he not?


Sherry now:
I don't remember one occasion when Snape and Crookshanks are in the same
room together.  

However, I don't think it is that Crookshanks knows a bad person when he
sees him.  Wasn't it that he knew Scabbers was a wizard?  That's different
than knowing that wizard was a bad one I think.

Sherry, who agrees with Alla that Buckbeak attacked Snape to protect Harry