Magical animals in canon/ Fawkes and Snape.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 166268

> colebiancardi:
> 
> ah, yes....Fawkes, who fought in the MoM battle alongside DD.  Where
> was Fawkes on that fated night in the Tower?  Why didn't he come to
> DD's aid when DD was in such need?  Why didn't he help Harry as 
Harry
> was battling Snape?
> 
> So, chalk up two loyal & intelligent animals that do not react in a
> negative manner towards Snape, whether thru actions read about or
> actions not mentioned.  in my humble opinion, of course

Alla:

Yes, I do wonder where was Fawkes, absolutely. Who knows, maybe Snape 
placed a spell on him or something? <g>

But I think that is a little bit of stretch to say that since Fawkes 
was not there, that means he did not react badly towards Snape . IMO 
of course.

Since JKR hinted that Fawkes will play a role in book 7, I am 
thinking we will see his reaction to Snape one way or another.

JMO,

Alla, who thinks that if Fawkes will sing for Snape then it will be 
rather strong indication of Snape loyalties indeed.