Magical animals in canon/ Fawkes and Snape.
Dana
ida3 at planet.nl
Mon Mar 19 18:42:38 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 166270
>
> > colebiancardi:
> > Where was Fawkes on that fated night in the Tower? Why didn't he
> > come to DD's aid when DD was in such need? Why didn't he help
> > Harry as Harry was battling Snape?
> >
<Snip>
> Alla:
>
>>
> Since JKR hinted that Fawkes will play a role in book 7, I am
> thinking we will see his reaction to Snape one way or another.
>
<snip>
Dana:
What if Fawkes wasn't there? He only started singing when everybody
was gathered in the hospital wing and Hagrid had taken DD's body
away. You can hear him on the grounds not just there. It seems to me
that if Fawkes was there then he would have started singing right
away and maybe JKR is sneaking a clue right behind us.
I am seriously thinking Fawkes was too busy with something else to
come to DD's aid.
Doing what? Well of course I have no idea but with Jen's possible
plan in the back of my mind, it might be transporting Trelawney out
of the castle and delivering a message maybe to DD's brother.
Dana
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive