[HPforGrownups] GoF fight between Harry and Ron (WAS:Re: On the perfection of moral)

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 168918

> <SNIP>
> 
Alla:
> 
> They are not people who just met, they are best friends, basically
brothers. I think Ron should have higher level of trust in Harry than what
he showed.
> 
> Yes, just because Harry said so IMO.
> 
> Again, this to me was the fight between friends, I certainly do not
think that it foreshadows Ron's betraying Harry or anything like that.
> 
> But no, I do not think that Ron should have trusted Harry only if
Harry gave him convincing reasons.
> 
> I did not do it should have been **more** than enough IMO.


Carol responds:
But do you agree that if Harry had told Ron the full truth, repeating
Fake!Moody's words, that Ron would have believed him?


Sherry;

No, I do not agree.  and I love Ron.  But I felt this was an incredible act
of disloyalty.  If my friend tells me something, and I have three years of
living with that friend to tell me that person is honest with me, then I
believe my friend, no matter what other evidence there might be, no
questions asked, no doubting.  I expect the same thing in return.  To me,
Ron was completely in the wrong, and it's to Harry's benefit that he can so
easily forgive, once Ron comes to his senses.

Sherry