Harry the Horcrux WAS:Re: The remaining Horcruxes....

[Gary]

No: HPFGUIDX 169028

TKJ:
> I don't like Nagini!Horcrux idea either. As for Harry!Horcrux, yes,
> I'm in this camp, but if it turns out to be true, I'm sure that JKR
> will find the way around it and Harry will survive, even though he
> will be ready to sacrifice himself. If Harry dies, I'll take it
> really, really hard ...

Gary:

I think my biggest objection to Harry as a horcrux is simply that LV
set out to kill infant Harry, and failing that, lost his powers. When
could he have possibly managed to embed his soul/essence in Harry?
Before he tried to kill him? If so, then why try to kill him. After he
failed to kill Harry? Then how did he summon the power to do so?

The only possible argument would be that he did not intend to kill
Harry when he cursed him, but did intend to make him his horcrux. But
that doesn't square with his obvious intention to kill Harry in the
graveyard in GoF. Why would he seek to destroy his own horcrux even if
he did have a new body?

I'm afraid there are just to many inconsistencies for me to accept the
Harry as horcrux scenario.