On the perfection of moral virtues/ Of Snape

[Dana]

No: HPFGUIDX 169036

Alla:
> 
> There are plenty things I agree with you in this post, but this 
> assumption that Snape indeed knew that DD was hiding stone from 
> Voldemort, I think has merit.
> 
> Unless of course you argue that teachers did not know what they 
> were defending. I mean, I guess one can argue that. But then I 
> picture this rather wierd little scene, when Dumbledore gathers the 
> teachers and tells them. Hey guys, please prepare the best defenses 
> you know. And what are we defending, Albus?
> 
> Something.  I mean, not that Dumbledore never keeps secret from his 
> teaching staff, LOL. But it still feels strange to me, if it is 
true.
<snip>

Dana:
How about someone is trying to steal the stone of my friend Flamel 
and I promised I would do anything to protect it ;o)
How many of the people in the WW knew that LV did not die and was 
gone for ever after the events in GH. 

Even if DD had the idea that it was for Voldemort it would only be 
his idea, why would he worry the teachers about Voldemort trying to 
return by using the stone if he wouldn't be sure about it himself. 
Actually he wouldn't. He would just state someone was trying to steal 
it and that would be enough explanation. 

Dana