Marietta

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 169451

juli17 at ... wrote: 

> we  are talking about a bunch 
> of FIFTEEN YEAR OLDS here 

The French resistance hung people younger than that who betrayed them
to the Nazis. Marietta just got acne. Lucky girl.

> This is schoolyard stuff

Is it schoolyard stuff to be betrayed to someone willing to torture
and murder you, is it schoolyard stuff to have your soul sucked out of
your mouth, is it schoolyard stuff to be tied to a tombstone and
tortured so horribly you literally want to die?

I already know what your defense of Marietta will be, it will be some
variation on the theme that the ideas bouncing around in her head were
incorrect so its OK that she did an evil thing. I don't buy it, you
need to pay a price if you're THAT wrong! And if Marietta didn't
understand what sort of person Umbridge is then she is a moral imbecile.

Eggplant