[HPforGrownups] Marietta

[random832 at fastmail.us]

No: HPFGUIDX 169454

eggplant:
> Is it schoolyard stuff to be betrayed to someone willing to torture
> and murder you, is it schoolyard stuff to have your soul sucked out of
> your mouth, is it schoolyard stuff to be tied to a tombstone and
> tortured so horribly you literally want to die?

None of which Marietta was aware of. (well, for the second she was
presumably aware of what Dementors do, just not that there was any
danger of it happening to any of them)

> And if Marietta didn't
> understand what sort of person Umbridge is then she is a moral imbecile.

Why? What evidence does she have in front of her that Umbridge is
capable of torture and murder? What reason does she have to believe
that, NOT knowing what we know?
-- 
  
  random832 at fastmail.us