SHIP Re: Why did JKR not explore H/Hr as canon?

Jaja Redor jajaredor at yahoo.com
Wed May 30 17:21:34 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 169531

        kmrhapsody:
To add to this fire, I must also say that her public diss of Hermione
was just rotten. To effectively shun the one person who has bothered
to notice and in her own way encourage the development of the "new
beloved Ginny" for the purposes of getting some cool points with Harry
was a pretty lousy move. 

  Jaja:
Agreed. I just cannot comprehend why Ginny has to attack the person who has helped her to get along with Harry? She embarrased Hermione in front of the others and for what? IMO, just so she can show to Harry that she'll back him up to whatever and wherever he'll do, which is not saying much at the end of HBP. Very contradicting..
   
  kmrhapsody:
Speaking of which, that is also the reason why I am still on the fence
on whether or not Hermione does have a crush on Ron, at the same level
as Ron does for her. She is always rooting for the underdog and made
many moves throughout the series to keep Ron in the fold and to
minimize his feelings of alienation. In return, Ron treats her rather
cruelly. She is never capable of doing anything right in his eyes and
is always at odds with him. That is why I think she attacked him with
the birds. I would have done the same. 

  Jaja:
Speaking for myself, I have been in a company of guys so I can relate to Hermione, actually, my best friend is a guy.. Honestly speaking, I get jealous whenever my best friend has GF but not because I want him for myself but because we'll have less time together.
  I read Hermione basically the same, at platonic level. So I don't think Hermione attacked Ron because of romantic issues. It could be interpreted by tons of of reasons and alibis, like she's annoyed of Ron because of his choice of GF (IMO, yes, it was very annoying that Won-won and Lav-lav were acting that way, it wasn't funny).
   
  Jaja


     




More information about the HPforGrownups archive